Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)

ECT quickly relieves severe depression symptoms and other psychiatric issues when other treatments fail. Under anesthesia, brief electrical stimulation to the brain can rapidly improve severe psychiatric syndromes, including those that have failed multiple other treatment modalities.

Compassionate Healing Starts Here

Click below to learn more about where you can find compassionate care.

Our team of subspecialists offers hope to patients with mood disorders through innovative treatments and compassionate care. We know that diagnosing mood disorders early is crucial to managing your condition and offering you the best quality of life. At UC Health, we focus on identifying predictors of mood disorders, as well as studying new interventions backed by leading research to bring you the best possible care.

To schedule an appointment, please call the UC Health Mood Disorders team at 513-585-MOOD (6663).

ABOUT THIS TREATMENT OPTION

Understanding Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)

What is ECT?

Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) has long been a cornerstone in treating severe mental health issues, especially when other methods have not succeeded. It's known for its rapid response in alleviating symptoms of severe depression, bipolar disorder, and other psychiatric conditions. This treatment involves a brief electrical stimulation to the brain while the patient is under anesthesia, which can quickly improve patients’ signs and symptoms of distress.

ECT is particularly helpful for patients who need swift improvement or those who have found limited relief from other treatment options. As you explore whether ECT might be right for you or your loved one, it’s important to understand both its effectiveness and the care with which it is administered to support recovery.

The ECT Treatment Process

Understanding the ECT procedure can help alleviate some of the anxiety that patients or their families might feel about this treatment. Here's what you can expect during the ECT process:

  1. Preparation: Before the procedure, the healthcare team will conduct a thorough evaluation, including medical history, to confirm that ECT is a suitable option. Patients will also undergo a brief physical examination to ensure they are healthy enough for anesthesia.
  2. Anesthesia and Muscle Relaxants: On the day of the treatment, patients receive general anesthesia and a muscle relaxant. This combination ensures that the patient is asleep and does not experience any discomfort or physical movement during the treatment.
  3. Electrical Stimulation: Once the patient is asleep, a carefully calibrated electrical current is applied through electrodes placed on the scalp. This current causes a brief, controlled seizure in the brain. While the thought of a seizure might be worrying, it is important to note that due to the muscle relaxant and anesthesia, the patient does not physically convulse and is not aware of the seizure.
  4. Monitoring and Recovery: Throughout the procedure, the patient’s brain activity, heart rate, and blood pressure are closely monitored by health care professionals. After the treatment, patients are moved to a recovery area where they are closely observed as the anesthesia wears off. The total recovery time can vary, but most people feel back to their normal selves within an hour.
  5. Follow-Up: ECT requires multiple sessions, typically administered two to three times a week for a total of six to twelve treatments. The exact number depends on the patient’s response and overall mental health progress.

Maintenance Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)

After the initial series of ECT sessions, some patients may require ongoing treatment to prevent relapse, known as maintenance ECT. This continuation therapy is tailored to each individual's needs based on their response to initial treatments and overall mental health status.

  • Schedule and Frequency: Maintenance ECT can vary from once a week to once every few months. The frequency is carefully determined to balance effectiveness with quality of life.
  • Monitoring and Adjustment: Ongoing monitoring of mental health, cognitive functions, and physical health is essential. Adjustments to the treatment plan, including changes in frequency and settings, are made based on this continuous assessment.
  • Long-Term Management: Maintenance ECT is part of a comprehensive mental health management plan that includes medications, psychotherapy, and lifestyle adjustments. It is particularly beneficial for patients with treatment-resistant depression or those who have experienced significant benefits from initial ECT sessions.

Benefits and Risks of Electroconvulsive Therapy

When considering any medical treatment, understanding both the potential benefits and risks is essential. Here’s what you should know about ECT:

Benefits of ECT

  • Quick Improvement: ECT often produces a rapid improvement in severe mental health conditions, which is particularly helpful for patients at risk of self-harm or severe impairment.
  • High Efficacy: For certain conditions like severe depression and treatment-resistant depression, ECT can be more effective than medication, including antidepressant medication, helping patients who haven’t responded to other treatments.
  • Safety Record: Despite misconceptions, ECT is safe when conducted under controlled medical settings. It is often used effectively for elderly patients and those with serious medical conditions who cannot tolerate drug therapy.

Risks of ECT

  • Memory Issues: Some patients may experience temporary memory loss, particularly for recent events around the time of treatment. This usually resolves within a few weeks, but everyone’s experience is different.
  • Physical Side Effects: Common side effects include headache, muscle soreness, and nausea immediately after treatment, which are generally manageable with medications.
  • Rare Complications: Like any procedure involving anesthesia, there is a small risk of more serious complications, such as heart problems, especially in patients with existing heart conditions.

ECT is an important treatment option, particularly effective for those with treatment-resistant depression. It’s important for patients and their families to discuss these benefits and risks with their healthcare provider to make an informed decision about whether ECT is the right option.

Preparing for Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)

Proper preparation for ECT can significantly enhance the treatment's effectiveness and the patient's comfort level. Here are key steps and considerations for patients and their families:

Before ECT

  • Medical and Psychological Evaluation: Before beginning treatment, patients undergo a comprehensive assessment to ensure ECT is suitable for their condition. This includes a detailed discussion of medical history, current medications, and any prior experiences with mental health treatments.
  • Informed Consent: Understanding and consenting to ECT is crucial. Patients will receive detailed information about the procedure, expected benefits, and potential risks to make an informed decision. It’s essential for patients and their families to ask questions and express any concerns they may have.

Day of Treatment

  • Fasting: Patients are required to fast—usually starting at midnight before the day of the treatment—to prepare for anesthesia.
  • Arrival at the Clinic: Arrive at the healthcare facility well in advance to complete any last-minute paperwork and settle in comfortably before the procedure begins.
  • Support System: Having a family member or friend for support on the day of treatment can be very reassuring for the patient.

Post-ECT Care

  • Transportation: Patients will need someone to drive them home after the treatment as they may feel groggy or disoriented temporarily due to the anesthesia.
  • Rest: It's advisable to take it easy for the rest of the day following an ECT session. Full activity can typically be resumed the next day.
  • Follow-Up Appointments: Regular follow-up appointments are crucial to monitor the patient's progress and make any necessary adjustments to the treatment plan.

Legal and Ethical Considerations of Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT)

Electroconvulsive Therapy, while highly effective, involves specific legal and ethical responsibilities both for healthcare providers and patients. Understanding these considerations is crucial for ensuring the treatment is administered with the highest standards of care.

Informed Consent

  • Thorough Explanation: Patients must receive a thorough explanation about the ECT process, what to expect during and after treatment, and the potential risks and benefits. This is to ensure that they are fully informed before consenting to treatment.
  • Voluntary Decision: Consent should be given freely without coercion. Patients have the right to withdraw consent at any time before the procedure.

Mental Health Act Compliance

  • Legal Requirements: ECT treatment must comply with the provisions of the Mental Health Act, which protects patients’ rights and ensures treatments are administered for the right reasons, under appropriate conditions.
  • Regular Reviews: Treatment plans involving ECT should be regularly reviewed by a committee or board, ensuring that all legal and ethical standards are continually met. Involvement of specialists from interventional psychiatry can help ensure these standards are upheld, focusing on the targeted application of treatments for psychiatric disorders.

Patient Rights

  • Right to Refuse: Patients can refuse ECT at any point. This decision must be respected and alternative treatments should be discussed.
  • Confidentiality and Privacy: Patients have the right to confidentiality concerning their treatment. Information about their mental health and personal details must be handled with utmost privacy and care.

Ethical Considerations

  • Best Interest: Decisions about using ECT should always be made with the patient’s best interests in mind, considering both the potential benefits and risks.
  • Professional Standards: Healthcare providers must adhere to the highest professional standards when recommending and administering ECT, ensuring it is used appropriately and effectively.

ECT in Special Populations: Considerations and Care

Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a versatile treatment that benefits a diverse range of patients, including those in special demographic groups. Each group may face unique challenges and considerations when undergoing ECT. Here’s how ECT is tailored to meet the needs of these specific populations:

Adolescent Psychiatry

  • Tailored Approaches: Adolescents receiving ECT require particular attention to dosage and monitoring, as their brains are still developing. Consent involves not only the young patient but also parental or guardian involvement.
  • School and Social Life: Treatment scheduling and recovery plans are designed to minimize disruption to educational and social activities, helping young patients maintain a normal routine as much as possible.

Adult Psychiatry

  • Work and Family Life: For adult patients, considerations include the timing of treatments to lessen impact on work and family responsibilities. Support systems and counseling are often recommended to help integrate treatment into their busy lives.

Geriatric Psychiatry

  • Age-Related Sensitivity: Elderly patients may have additional medical conditions that require careful management during ECT. They often respond differently to anesthesia and recovery may take longer, necessitating a customized approach to their treatment and care.

Special Medical Conditions

  • Comorbidities: Patients with comorbid conditions such as heart disease or diabetes require integrated care plans that address both their psychiatric and physical health needs during ECT.

Cultural and Ethical Considerations

  • Cultural Sensitivity: Understanding and respecting cultural backgrounds and beliefs about mental health treatment is crucial. This includes providing information and counseling in a way that is respectful and appropriate to the patient's cultural context.

Ongoing Research and Training for ECT

Advancements in ECT Through Clinical Trials

Clinical trials play a pivotal role in advancing the efficacy and safety of ECT. These studies help medical professionals understand the best practices for administering ECT and identify new areas for improvement. Participation in clinical trials is essential for developing better treatment protocols and outcomes, particularly for populations that are less commonly studied.

The Role of Medical Education in ECT

Medical education is critical in ensuring that the latest and most effective ECT techniques are taught to upcoming psychiatrists and medical staff. By integrating the latest research findings from clinical trials into educational curricula, medical institutions ensure that the healthcare professionals administering ECT are well-prepared and informed. This ongoing education helps maintain high standards of patient care and treatment integrity across the board.

Help Along the Way

Answers to Your Questions about Electroconvulsive therapy

Electroconvulsive therapy is a specialized treatment used when other forms of therapy, such as medication and psychotherapy, are not effective. It's used widely across psychiatric care, especially for severe depression, certain cases of bipolar disorder, and more recently, schizophrenia. The frequency of use varies by condition and individual patient needs, making it an essential part of modern psychiatry.

ECT is valuable for treating certain symptoms of schizophrenia, particularly when patients show resistance to antipsychotic medications. It can alleviate acute symptoms such as severe delusions and hallucinations, offering rapid improvement in cases where other treatments have not been effective.

ECT is often used in conjunction with medications and psychotherapy to provide a comprehensive treatment approach. For many patients, ECT can enhance the effectiveness of antidepressants or serve as a bridge to longer-term therapies, enabling a multifaceted strategy for managing mental health conditions.

Recent clinical trials have focused on refining ECT techniques to improve efficacy and reduce side effects. Advancements include individualized dosing strategies, improved anesthesia methods, and the development of ultra-brief pulse ECT, which has shown to lessen cognitive side effects while maintaining effectiveness.

Common misconceptions include beliefs that ECT is painful or causes permanent brain damage. Modern ECT is performed under anesthesia to ensure it's pain-free, and multiple studies have shown it does not cause brain damage. Current practices prioritize patient comfort and safety, continually supported by ongoing research.

Patient safety during ECT is ensured through pre-treatment medical evaluations, monitoring during the procedure by skilled health care professionals, and the use of modern anesthesia techniques. Protocols are in place for emergency situations, and treatments are tailored to individual health profiles.

Innovations include the use of refined electrode placements and individualized electrical dosing, which have been shown to minimize memory issues. Research into the timing and frequency of treatments also aims to optimize cognitive outcomes, making ECT a safer option with fewer side effects.

Success is determined by improvements in symptom severity, the return of normal functioning, and the patient's quality of life post-treatment. Health care professionals use a combination of psychiatric evaluations, patient self-reports, and observations from family or caregivers to assess the effectiveness of ECT.

Yes, ECT can be highly customized. Variables such as the electrical current strength, electrode placement, and number of treatments are adjusted based on individual patient factors, including the severity of symptoms, previous responses to treatments, and overall health status, to provide personalized care.

One survey found that following ECT, most patients reported it was no worse than going to the dentist and many even found ECT less stressful. Many psychiatric illnesses result in impairment of attention and concentration. Consequently, when psychiatric disturbance improves following ECT, a vast majority of patients report improvement in these aspects of thinking. They also report that if needed, they would receive ECT treatment again.

Brain imaging studies following ECT have shown no damage in the structure or composition of the brain. The amount of electricity used in ECT is so small that it cannot cause electrical injury.

TMS and ECT are both procedures that treat major depression. The important differences between TMS therapy and ECT include:

  • ECT requires anesthesia whereas TMS does not
  • ECT applies electrical energy to the whole brain, while TMS uses magnetic energy applied only to the left prefrontal cortex
  • TMS therapy is a non-invasive procedure that does not require anesthesia and does not produce a seizure

With any treatment, patients and clinicians should work together to determine the most appropriate option.

Contact Us

At UC Health, we lead the region in scientific discoveries and embrace a spirit of purpose – offering our patients and their families something beyond everyday healthcare. At UC Health, we offer hope.